On November 28 2012, the Huffington Post published the following Canadian Press article after the then President-elect Enrique Peña Nieto visited Prime Minister Harper in Ottawa:
--
OTTAWA - The end of a much-maligned visa for
Mexican travellers to Canada
would be a good thing for both North American countries, Prime Minister Stephen
Harper affirmed Wednesday. Harper offered his government's most
conciliatory view to the visa that it imposed in 2009 to stop an influx of
bogus refugee claimants. It came after his Parliament Hill meeting with Mexico's
president-elect Enrique Pena Nieto.
Mexico was stung by the visa requirement, viewing it as
heavy-handed and unexpected.
"We would ultimately like to see visa-free travel with Mexico,"
Harper said at a joint news conference,
standing next to the new, young telegenic Mexican leader, who
will be sworn in Saturday as president. But first, the government is
working to change its immigration system first so there is not a recurrence of
past problems, Harper added. "We have changed laws. We're in the
process of changing our systems," said Harper. It would be in
the interest of both countries to get rid of the visa, he added.
--
Fast forward to April 2013. The Canadian Government has revamped the Refugee System, it has published a list of Safe Countries, which includes Mexico. Yet, there has been no movement, that we can tell regarding the lifting of Visa restrictions on Mexican visitors. While I would welcome the lifting of the visa restrictions for Mexican tourists, this post is not about that. This post is about the current visa issuing process which at times seems the most inefficient and incompetent of processes. The current issue is not whether the applicants get a visitor visa (temporary resident visa) or not. The issue is that decisions are not always made in a timely manner. According to the CIC website (http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/information/times/temp/visitors.asp#west)
, the average time it takes to process a visitor visa application from Mexico is 11 days (80% of the time). But as in the case described below, some applications are delayed almost indefinitely. Now, if these were permanent resident applications, I can understand that, but in the case of tourists, there should be a clear timeline for all applications so that tourists can properly plan their vacations. Would you plan a trip to any country if you knew that you may or may not get a visa and it may or may not take an indefinite amount of time? Of course not!
Talk to any Mexican tour operator (and countless Mexicans) that assists their customers in the visitor visa application process and all of them will have horror stories to tell.
Here's a an example of what I'm posting about here: a letter from my Mexican client, a well respected travel professional who is a former CTC representative in Mexico.
"Dear
Canadian Tourism Partners,
I regret to inform you that we
will not participate in Rendez Vous Canada this year.
As you know, I have
distinguished myself as a huge fan of Canada and its people since
my days as the CTC’s
representative in Mexico.
However, on this occasion it is very
difficult for me to think about
Canada
without a sense of frustration and disappointment.
I think it is necessary for you
to know what is going on with Canada’s
visa office at the
Canadian Embassy in Mexico. While
we understand that there are thousands of Mexicans
applying for visitors and other
visas, we feel that the way the process is being managed is
not conducive to a productive
relationship. When we try to ask about delays in processing
visas for some of our
customers, we are faced with automatic email responses that do
not give us any information
other than saying the evaluation is in progress. Because we
understand there is a heavy
workload at the Embassy, we do not ask for information
without first waiting a
reasonable time for the visas to be approved or denied. According
to the Embassy’s own
information, the average time for a visitor’s visa to be processed in
Mexico is about 11 days.
Last February 21st, we
submitted an application for visitors’ visas for a family of four
who have been long time clients
of ours. In fact, this family has vacationed in Canada
before. All the documentation
was in order when we submitted it, and if anything at
all was missing we have never
been informed. Our clients were scheduled to travel
on March 24, Easter vacation.
To this day we have not received a positive or negative
response from the Embassy. It’s
been over a month (or 21 business days). As business
people, you can understand how
frustrating this is. We are not demanding that the visa
officials approve all our
customers’ requests for visas. All we would ask is to get a
response in a timely manner.
Obviously, this family lost their trip to Canada and are still
frustrated by the fact that
they haven’t received a response from the Canadian Embassy.
We all want repeat business for
Canadian destinations, but it is very unlikely that this
family (and any of their friends
who listen to their story) will want to vacation in Canada
anytime soon. We tried
contacting officials at the Canadian Embassy regarding this issue,
but all that achieved was more
frustration and disappointment. I am sure you would get
frustrated too. The only
response we get is that there’s nothing they can do and to just
keep waiting. In the meantime,
we have to apologize profusely to the clients and persuade
them to purchase their travel
with us. To another destination!
The above case is not the only
one we’ve had to deal with, although it’s one of the worst.
We’ve had many instances
wherein the process is less than stellar. You can ask any
operator in Mexico and I
can assure you they have similar stories.
In light of all this, it is
with regret and disappointment that we are cancelling our
participation in Rendez Vous Canada next
month. The investment in time and money
necessary to attend RVC is not
the best use of our resources at this time. As most other
Mexican operators, we sell a
great variety of destinations – over 50 countries - to our
Mexican customers. When it
comes to visas, no other country has been more difficult
than Canada. Assisting our customers
with their applications takes an enormous amount
of time. Therefore, while we
will continue to sell Canada,
we will focus more of our
promotional efforts on other
destinations.
I want to reiterate my
continuing admiration and respect for all of you, for Canada and
its people. I hope that your
Prime Minister follows through with his implied promises
that once Canada’s
Refugee System had been fixed and the list of safe countries (of
which Mexico is a part) was in place, that Canada would
lift visa restrictions on Mexican
visitors – as your own Globe
and Mail, The Centre for International Governance
Innovation (CIGI) and The
Canadian Chamber of Commerce have recommended. This
would clearly change things and
return Mexico to its
rightful place among Canada’s
most
important markets for tourism.
With warmest regards,
S. Morales"
This kind of situation is a loss for Canada. Given that Canada requires visitor visas from all our current growth inbound markets (India, China, Brazil, Mexico), if the visa application process is too difficult, what do you think travelers will do? Right now, I am working with my Mexican client on a digital/social media campaign to sell travel to Europe and South America for the coming summer season, and it's starting to yield such good results, that Canada is falling to the back of the line.
Are you involved in selling travel to Canada from visa required countries? What has been your experience? Comments? Suggestions?